Opinion article in the Australian Financial Review by Samantha McCulloch, Chief Executive of Australian Energy Producers, 18 November 2026.
The debate over a domestic gas reservation policy has been reduced to a false choice between backing manufacturers or gas producers.
Australia needs both. A strong gas industry and a competitive manufacturing sector are essential to a functioning market and to continued investment in new supply.
A well-designed reservation policy can help strike that balance.
As it stands, the federal government’s reservation policy is set to leave Australian manufacturers and the nation’s energy security worse off in the long term.
By forcing Queensland gas exporters to sell into an already well-supplied market, potentially below the cost of producing the gas, it will crowd out domestic-focused producers and undermine investment in new supply.
Modelling by global analytics firm Wood Mackenzie has found the proposed scheme could displace up to 39 petajoules a year of gas from domestic-focused producers. To put that in context, that’s roughly how much gas the whole east coast uses in a month.
Over time, the market share for domestic-focused producers will be squeezed from more than two-thirds today to about 40 per cent in 2045.
A reservation policy that drives out domestic producers, reduces competition and destroys investment signals is not in the national interest.
The government says the scheme will put downward pressure on gas prices. But any sugar hit of artificially low prices will not last.
As Wood Mackenzie found, once domestic-focused producers are driven out because they cannot sustainably sell below cost, and investment in new supply dries up, prices will quickly rebound.
Eventually, that could leave the east coast structurally undersupplied from the early 2040s, increasing the risk of reliance on imported LNG and exposure to international prices.
This is at odds with the government’s stated objective of restoring long-term stability to the gas market.
Australian gas producers support a prospective reservation scheme that encourages investment in new supply, secures long-term domestic gas availability and preserves Australia’s role as a reliable LNG trading partner.
With fundamental amendments, the scheme can still achieve this, but only if parliament puts the long-term interests of all gas users ahead of the short-term interests of some manufacturers.
Large manufacturers insist the scheme should retain the proposed “must sell” and structural oversupply requirements, even if it forces east coast gas producers to sell at a loss.
Manufacturers are incorrectly and disingenuously claiming the cost of the scheme to the gas industry is $134 million. But this is just the government’s estimate of the cost of administering the scheme.
It’s not the cost to the economy, to export income or to the regional communities that rely on a strong gas industry. Inexplicably, those costs have not been modelled.
In effect, large manufacturers are asking the gas industry to subsidise their operations with artificially cheap gas – an extraordinary and short-sighted proposition.
Yet, by design, this is what the legislation will do. The government’s own impact analysis concedes the policy will result in a “transfer of value from gas producers to domestic users” and could reduce LNG exports, gas production and investment.
Cheaper gas will not fix the competitiveness challenges facing Australian manufacturing.
Wood Mackenzie analysed the gas costs of 13 of the largest east coast industrial gas users and found they average less than 5 per cent of total costs.
Reducing the gas price for those facilities from $12 to $10/GJ would lower their combined gas costs by less than $100 million against total operating costs of almost $20 billion. Profit margins would improve by less than half a per cent.
Fixing the design
The reservation scheme is the third major intervention in the east coast gas market in almost as many years and, like the price caps and Gas Market Code before it, prioritises short-term price outcomes over an enduring policy framework.
Australia cannot afford another failed market intervention.
The Australian Energy Market Operator and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission have confirmed east coast gas prices are the lowest in years, and the market is well supplied until at least 2029. But investment in new supply and infrastructure is critical to avoid shortfalls beyond that, especially in southern states.
Australia has enough undeveloped gas resources to supply households and businesses for decades while capturing the economic and strategic opportunity of growing LNG demand in our region.
While far from perfect, the legislation before parliament is the best chance to get this right. Gas producers, users, government and opposition agree the existing gas policy framework is not working for anyone, and a well-designed reservation policy can be part of the solution.
This consensus should be the foundation for genuine consultation and negotiations.
To fix the design, the reservation should be calibrated to actual market demand and allow gas offered on commercial terms but not needed domestically to be exported.
This would align the national scheme more closely with Western Australia’s reservation model.
WA Premier Roger Cook has rightly argued the national scheme should not override the state’s long-standing reservation policy. It appears the government has listened to WA’s concerns and will make it clearer that WA is exempt. This certainty should also extend to Northern Territory LNG exporters, which have limited connection to the east coast market.
A framework that encourages investment, strengthens competition and brings more gas to market will deliver lower prices and greater long-term energy security than one that simply redistributes an ever-diminishing pie.